2015 Downtown Business Review: How Did We Do?

Holly's 135, 135 S. Gay Street, Knoxville, February 2015
Holly’s 135, 135 S. Gay Street, Knoxville, February 2015

We’re going to look at the year that was from a couple of different angles. We’ll start with business openings and closings since that’s often a good measure of economic health. I’m going to restrict my examination to businesses which actually opened – not those that I wrote about and which haven’t opened as of the final day of the year. I’m also not looking at housing or other building rehabs and construction.

Those of you who read this blog regularly will remember that 2014 ended on a particularly sour note. Three businesses on Market Square closed at once and actually followed another downtown closing. The new year got off to a shaky start with the closing of the Peanut Shop and Shuck, though that was countered somewhat by the January opening of Waldorf Photographic Art on Main Street.

From that point on, the openings dominated the closures and the openings included a wide range of businesses. February saw the opening of an art studio (Zach Searcy Projects), a furniture store (Boxwood Brake) and a restaurant (Holly’s 135). We lost Aisle 9 in the Old City, but the ratio of 3:1 for the month and the diversity of the openings served as encouragement after the recent closings.

Scott Angelius and Kelly Arsenault of K-Town Swing, Dance Class at 125 W. Jackson, Knoxville, Spring 2015
Scott Angelius and Kelly Arsenault of K-Town Swing, Dance Class at 125 W. Jackson, Knoxville, Spring 2015

From that point on, the openings dominated the closings. March saw the beginning of publication for our new independent newspaper, the Knoxville Mercury, the opening of Sweet P’s and the moving of the Knox Heritage Salvage Shop closer to downtown. April delivered a boutique (The Impeccable Pig) and a photography studio (Red Door) on Market Square and a new dance group (K-Town Swing). Laurel Mountain Eatery closed that month and Re-runs closed the next.

For the month of June we broke even with the opening of the Basement Community Art Studio and a new boutique inside Hot Horse Records in the Old City and the move from downtown by the Parlor and a move to a different business model prompted Boxwood Brake (which had opened only months earlier) to close their brick and mortar store. Incredibly, there would only be two more closings (Cafe du Soleil and Rococo) for the year and one store moved (Remedy).

Matthew Cummings Studio, 133 S. Central, Knoxville, August 2015
Matthew Cummings Studio, 133 S. Central, Knoxville, August 2015

The openings, however continued and escalated dramatically. July brought Frussies to one end of Gay Street and Painting with a Twist to the other. Six openings in August included Barre Belle Yoga, Alliance Brewing, Downtown Yoga, Park City Cigar, The Hive and Matthew Cummings Studio. The diversity and pace continued with the September openings of All Occasions Catering in their first permanent home, Wild Lavender Spa, the second Coldstream Market location and Agora.

The last quarter of the year saw an explosion of openings. October brought Good Golly Tamale, Marble City Kitchen/Firefly, Crafty Bastard, Bar Marley, Central Collective and the Phoenix Pharmacy. November proved to be the most active month for openings and businesses moving to downtown, Geo Hair Lab, Folly Boutique, the Oliver Royale, Pedal Java, 2 Roads, Three Bears Coffee Company and Babalu. Capping the excellent year – and in contrast to the bad ending of the previous year – December produced openings by Wild Love Bakehouse, Knox Whiskey Works, Remedy Coffee‘s new location, Market House Cafe and a new home for Graphic House.

Crafty Bastard Brewery, 6 Emory Place, Knoxville, October 2015
Crafty Bastard Brewery, 6 Emory Place, Knoxville, October 2015

It is stunning when listed out that way, isn’t it? The voices saying downtown Knoxville will fail have largely been quieted, but this simple list really stands as a testament to the amazing explosion of this relatively small area. I count forty-two openings and nine closings. I may have missed a couple one way or the other and you might argue whether one or another should count and how, but the trend is overwhelming any way you slice it.

Equally as important as the volume of openings is the diversity of openings. If we are to be a vibrant downtown, and particularly if we want to have a sustainable, walkable residential downtown, we must have a diversity of businesses. Witness that of the forty-two openings listed only seven are restaurants and one is a bar – both of which readers sometimes express frustration at having in excess downtown. I count twenty-one different kinds of businesses including some that are very important to downtown growth like furniture stores, a pharmacy and alternative forms of entertainment.

April Brown serves teh Cappuccino, Market House Cafe, 36 Market Square, Knoxville, December 2015
April Brown serves teh Cappuccino, Market House Cafe, 36 Market Square, Knoxville, December 2015

As I said at the outset, this does not include the explosion of development of other kinds, including housing. Announcements seem to be made weekly about new projects. I’ve already written about businesses which will be opening early next year and there are others I’ll write about soon. Please support these great new businesses so they will be here next year. They need your help to survive. It’s truly an exciting time to live in and be a part of this special place.