Snapshots & Stories from ‘Spirits of Old Gray’

Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.
Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.

Editor’s note: Today’s story is the happy result of two timely emails that landed in my inbox regarding last Sunday’s Spirits of Old Gray at Old Gray Cemetery. The event brings Knoxville history to life through costumed re-enactors portraying some of the just-north-of-downtown cemetery’s permanent residents, with self-guided exploration and organized walking tours. I really wanted to go but it fell at the exact same time as our kiddo’s school fall festival.

One email came from local photography legend Gary Heatherly, who documented the event including some incredible drone shots, and generously offered to share. The other came from Ed White, a longtime volunteer “spirit” who this year portrayed Peter Kern, the German immigrant, baker, entrepreneur and former Knoxville mayor, whom I coerced into a writeup. I mean, it’s Halloween week. What better time to hear from Knoxville’s dearly departed? Enjoy, and pay the cemetery a visit yourself this week as I will be; it’s an experience. — Leslie

Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.
Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.

The Spirits of Old Gray Tour took place this past Sunday, and from all accounts was one of the best Tours yet. Ellen Rochelle, the executive director of Old Gray Cemetery, gave me a quick estimate that at least 800 people attended based on gross ticket sales. But she thinks the number is likely much higher considering that children are let in free, and some discounts are given.

This year featured 12 different Spirits, re-enactors telling stories of people buried there, plus: bagpipes provided by Katie Helms, walking tours offered by Jack Neely and Laura Stills, food vendors, and of course, the other kind of spirits you might say, beer and wine.

These Tours are partly a fundraising event — you wouldn’t believe the cost just for groundskeeping the place, which is a Level I Certified Arboretum (editor’s note: more on that in a guest column from arborist Jim Cortese soon!). The Cemetery is also 501(c)(3) nonprofit, and an important part of their mission is to provide community education, promoting local history.

Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.
Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.

So let’s talk history a bit. Old Gray Cemetery is a very special place near downtown Knoxville, 13 acres of rolling hills with majestic trees and beautiful monuments, statuary, obelisks and elaborate stones dedicated to those buried there. People always remark upon how picturesque it is, “almost like a park,” they say. That happens to be by design.

Established in 1850, Old Gray is an example of the rural or garden cemetery movement of the day. It was specifically designed as a kind of public park, at a time when there wasn’t a city park in Knoxville, and it served that purpose for much of its history. At one time, Emory Place across Broadway from the cemetery was a stop on the trolley line that ran from downtown to Fountain City. People would stop there to visit Old Gray for picnics, dates, family gatherings. It’s named for the poet Thomas Gray, who wrote the inspirational “Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard,” which was becoming a staple of public education by the mid-to-late 1800s.

The Tour wasn’t always in October. It was originally scheduled for the last Sunday in September every year. But by the late 2010s, climate change was bringing us 90-degree weather. Besides dampening attendance, the heat was particularly oppressive for any re-enactors with period costumes, which are often wool. So the event got moved to the fourth Sunday in October, which has been much more comfortable for everybody.

Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.
Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.

And it wasn’t always called the Spirits of Old Gray. The original title of the event was the Lantern & Carriage Tour.  When the event was paused due to COVID in 2020, it gave the board the chance to reorganize the event, changing the day and the name in the process.

Every year before the event, we have a dinner for the Spirits and the board of directors to gather and discuss the Old Gray residents being featured, their stories.  When I arrive at the restaurant I tell the hostess, “I’m looking for the Old Gray people…”. I can barely suppress my amusement. Many of us are nowadays. Gray, that is. And old, variously, if that’s not too unkind. Enough so that the younger people who have been joining us more and more are breaths of fresh air we couldn’t do without. Keep’em coming.

Steve Cotham, the now-retired manager of the McClung Historical Collection downtown, is pretty sure it started in 2001, after he convinced the executive director of the cemetery board Alix Dempster that such an event was needed. They in turn convinced a young McClung historian Danette Welch to volunteer to help them plan the events, helping pick themes and the Old Gray residents to be highlighted. Danette has written most of the biographical narratives given to each re-enactor in all the years since. Alix remained a driving force until her passing in 2017, while Steve is still helping guide things today.

Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.
Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.

My first event was maybe 2004, and it was a hard one to top, for me. Paired with Nancy Brennan Strange, we portrayed Pattie Boyd and Ole Bull Jones, a colorful, “unconventional” couple, unmarried and living together, in the early decades of the last century. Pattie was the Society Editor at the Knoxville Journal, a position of power that worked like a protective shield we assume, and Ole (pronounced “O-lee”) was a locally famous violinist and composer. We sang a lovely duet for the crowds, and finished with a story about how Pattie kept a place set for Ole at the table at society dinners long after he died, very sweet.

That’s the power of the Spirits Tour: the personal stories. A never-ending supply of them, whose faceted stories intersect in so many fascinating ways. There’ve been a lot of different talents on offer over the years, real memorable characters themselves. We’ve had Civil War re-enactors like John Hitt and Matt Lakin; story tellers like Kathryn Atkins-Roberson; actors like Robbie Griffith, Bill Howard, and Redpaint and Dottie Spilman; and a whole range of folks who learned from the ground up.  We’ve also had descendants of Old Gray residents tell the stories of their own relatives, as four members of the Pettinger family did this year.

This year’s loose theme was the Centennial Week celebrations in Knoxville in 1876, to bookend our current Semiquincentennial. But not all the Spirits were connected to that. Linda William portrayed Lizzie Crozier French, for example, and Cheri VanBynen was the spirit of Eugenia Williams.

Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.
Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.

But as usual, being a re-enactor means that I’m not able to take the tour myself and see and hear all the other stories being told, the one bittersweet element for all the re-enactors every year. So let me share what others have told me about their impressions of the Spirits of Old Gray this year, from both sides of the fourth wall.

From Mark Lackey, who re-enacted John Fletcher Lackey this year: “Spending time in his head to share his fascinating life with others has been really special. I was talking to some of the other reenactors yesterday and I realized that every stone, and in many cases no stone, in Old Gray represents a story of a life worth studying and knowing about, historically and socially. Reality is often more exciting than fiction and life takes on a whole new meaning. I think it’s an honor and a great responsibility to represent someone’s life.”

From Cheri VanBynen, who portrayed Eugenia Williams this year: “I think Spirits of Old Gray is one of Knoxville’s best events! I brought my kids when they were small and several years ago my youngest and I got involved. We love story telling, doing research, learning about history, and costumes! We convey to listeners not only about our characters life but also what was going on in the world at that time. Eugenia spoke of disease, wars, transportation, and fashion – did you know we didn’t even have sliced bread till the 1920s? She lived 1900-1998 so there was a lot to cover.”

Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.
Spirits of Old Gray, Old Gray Cemetery, 543 N. Broadway, October 2026. Photo courtesy of Gary Heatherly.

And lastly, I asked attendee Alison Tipton to share her thoughts with us. She’s been attending these events almost since the beginning with her children, many of whom I’ve watched grow up over the years at Old Gray, one day per year. “My children love to hear stories about places they have a connection with. Few people (not even a history teacher’s kids) will happily sit down with a lengthy article about what happened on Gay Street in 1872, but everyone loves a good story, particularly a ‘personal’ story. That sticks with people, especially children. We love the costumes and the personal perspectives. My kids have said they help make the individuals portrayed feel like what they are, real people who really lived and really died. History can seem remote to many people, and this event is fabulous at helping us ponder what life would have been like long ago, and often see how far we’ve come. Or what we may have lost.

“This year’s Spirits of Old Gray was a wonderful one! The number and variety of the re-enactors may have been one of the best yet. I can tell everyone pulled out all the stops for the semiquincentennial year. We’re looking forward to the continuation of the event and hopefully some day becoming a part of it!”

Speaking personally, and I’m sure all the Old Gray folks would agree, these kinds of testimonial thoughts are exactly what we’re doing this for. We couldn’t do it without the hundreds of people attending every year, participating in history synergistically with us, making it happen. Come out and spend an afternoon with us this time next year — and if you can, be sure to visit the website (https://oldgraycemetery.org/) and hit the donate button at the bottom of the page!


Discover more from Inside of Knoxville

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.