
On Tuesday the City of Knoxville proposed a meaty investment in two aging public facilities that desperately need it: $10 million to replace the Knoxville Convention Center’s HVAC, and $60 million for a combination of pragmatic and experiential upgrades at the Knoxville Civic Auditorium and Coliseum. City Council will consider the proposal to issue $70 million in 20-year bonds at its Nov. 24 meeting.
Knoxville Civic Auditorium and Coliseum (KCAC) improvements would include a redesigned entrance, more comfortable auditorium seating, renovated lobbies and restrooms, accessibility upgrades and substantial behind-the-scenes work. Much of the mechanical, electrical and plumbing infrastructure dates to 1961, and the City says modernization would prevent costly emergency repairs and potential closures.

Personally, I think an industrial-strength pressure washing of this entire Gotham City-esque block would work wonders (and, while we’re at it, please run its grubby brutalist-fever-dream neighbor Vision at Knoxville through the carwash as well; update on that development later in this story). These folks must have made a killing on concrete in that era:

But while heralded in its youth as a harbinger of growth and progress …


… and still utilitarian enough, KCAC has been winning no popularity contests in recent years. I’m quite certain that my predecessor, Urban Guy, would drive a bulldozer straight through the Auditorium’s front lobby if given the opportunity. In one of his final, legendary, scorched-earth editorials before retiring, “Hey Knoxville, Can We Think Big?,” he suggested building a modern performing arts center on the former Safety Building site just up the hill, then demolishing the Auditorium and Coliseum and restoring the historic street grid. A 2014 study by the Urban Land Institute recommended much the same, urging us to essentially “cut our losses.”

Knoxville Opera CEO Jason Hardy responded with an op-ed envisioning a flexible new facility with performance, rehearsal and administrative space. Big Ears founder Ashley Capps chimed in with support for a similarly sized or larger state-of-the-art venue. The Auditorium’s 2,500 capacity is a tier above the Tennessee Theatre’s roughly 1,645 and useful in some instances, such as big-ticket Big Ears shows.
The need exists. Beyond its somewhat random and frequently milquetoast programming, the Auditorium remains a relied-upon venue for local arts groups, particularly the Knoxville Symphony Orchestra’s Pops series and Appalachian and Oak Ridge Ballets. But every time I’m there, it’s hard not to wince at the disconnect between the energy onstage and the tired surroundings.

And then there’s the adjoining Civic Coliseum (capacity: 6,500-seats), which tends to be underrepresented in culture-centric conversations though historically it has far surpassed the Auditorium in fielding huge music acts. Today, a sort of inverse effect has taken place as, while multi-use, the Coliseum is probably now best known as the longtime home of the Knoxville Ice Bears.
With specific logistical needs and no other feasible venue in sight, our hometown hockey team would understandably prefer to shelter in place. From the team’s general manager and executive vice president Dave Feather: “As the Ice Bears celebrate our 25th season, we’re proud to call the Knoxville Civic Coliseum home. When you see someone who grew up coming to games walk through those doors with their own kids, you understand what this building means to Knoxville.”
So, what exactly does this building mean to Knoxville? What has it meant in the past, and what could it mean in the future?

I: MONEY
The inconvenient truth of “thinking big” in a traditional sense, of course, is that’s usually bigly expensive. I confirmed with City of Knoxville deputy communications director Erik Vreeland that a demolition/rebuild would cost an estimated $300 million, which we’d need to save up our lunch money for a long time to afford.
Could a well-executed makeover do the trick? How far would $60 million go toward bringing these rather threadbare pieces of civic furniture into the 21st century? Could this be the start of a game-changing transformation, or are we just throwing good money after bad, kicking the can down the road?
The City has been grappling with these questions for a while. A 2016 feasibility study, which Alan wrote about and readers commented extensively upon here, explored options from modest upgrades to complete replacement. (Sadly, the original study seems to have “taken a hike in the Urban Wilderness,” which made me laugh but also, like, hey man, you can’t just like disappear relevant historical public information like that. It goes to reinforce the importance of local journalism to document this sort of thing in the moment.)
Anyway, at the end of the day the City invested another $10 million in improvements in 2018-19. Now we’re considering $60 million more. Still, it’s one-fifth the price tag of a full rebuild.

Speaking of money, where is that proposed $70 million coming from? In the 48 hours following the City’s proposal announcements, concerns circulated widely on social media about spending so much on tourism-related facilities while our community faces pressing needs around housing, homelessness, infrastructure and essential services. It’s an understandable response to very real anxieties and vulnerabilities, many of which are rooted in systemic problems well upstream of City Hall.
These particular public facility upgrades, however, aren’t an either/or proposition. A breakdown of the funding: Mayor Kincannon included a $25 million lump-sum payment on the Convention Center’s remaining debt in her FY 2025-26 budget, reducing annual payments by approximately $4 million and saving taxpayers $30.2 million over time.
The proposed bonds would add about $5.3 million in annual debt payments, with $4 million covered by hotel/motel tax revenues legally restricted to tourism-related purposes. Essentially, last year’s early payment freed up room for much of the new expense. Even with the new bonds, the City says Knoxville’s debt load would remain relatively low compared with other Tennessee cities of similar or larger size.
That doesn’t make the larger debate over public spending priorities any less important. But this isn’t $70 million in available cash that could simply be redirected to other needs. It’s a borrowing decision with most of the repayment coming from a dedicated revenue source with restrictions on how it gets spent.
Having said that, I imagine there’s a way to PROGRESS our vision for these spaces and how they can serve the community, too. KCAC was originally envisioned as a true municipal resource, rentable to whomever needed space.

Times change and needs evolve, sometimes gradually and sometimes all at once. In 2005, for instance, the Knoxville Fire Department set up hundreds of cots inside the Coliseum to shelter Hurricane Katrina evacuees arriving from the Gulf Coast. I know because I was there, reporting for Metro Pulse, and some of the heartbreaking stories I heard during those weeks still haunt me.
Even without tearing the whole thing down and reimagining it from scratch, surely there’s room here to “think bigger” about how KCAC can serve its community, whether that means renting space to community groups and churches, stepping up as a warming center, or whatever else the unpredictable future throws our way.

I’ve also seen folks suggest turning to private benefactors, those familiar family names whose generosity already underwrites so much of Knoxville’s vibrant cultural scene.
I’d counter that they’ve done plenty, they don’t owe us anything, and frankly, from the outside looking in, we’ve done little to demonstrate KCAC’s historic or present-day value, much less articulate what role it could play in Knoxville’s future. While private investment would certainly be welcome, it’s time for the City to take a harder look at KCAC’s revenue streams and its potential to serve a city that looks much different than it did 65 years ago.

II: CONNECTION
Mayor Kincannon’s proposal arrives at a pivotal moment. Long an under-activated and disused superblock still wincing from the shame of Urban Renewal, the KCAC and its surrounding areas are now on the cusp of transformation on multiple fronts and an opportunity to course-correct some historic wrongs. Its future looks a lot different from its present when the Urban Land Institute evaluated it over a decade ago and wrote off its relevancy, suggesting that the auditorium and coliseum, in addition to being doomed by a lifeless, road-strangled location outside downtown, had surpassed their functional lives and that the city should look at building new facilities elsewhere.
Well, things are changing.
A brief inventory:

Immediately uphill from KCAC, the future of the former Public Safety Building site is in the thick of a public input process led by Knoxville’s Community Development Corporation and the City to help determine its future. After community sessions in September and October (I wrote about that here, including a deeper dive into the impact of Urban Renewal), an online survey remains available so be sure to go weigh in if you haven’t already.

Meanwhile, we’ve got some 569 new apartments coming online in the very near future just across the James White Parkway chasm (but connected by a pedestrian bridge that I’d literally forgotten about until yesterday) in the Riverhill District.

The Aster is accepting applications for its 194 apartments, with move-ins expected to begin Dec. 1. There are studio, 1-, 2- and 3-bedroom apartments with amenities like a pool, sky deck and lounge, golf simulator, sauna and more.


I also spoke this week with the contractor of the 375-unit Vision at Knoxville (I shared a sneak peek at the interior over the summer here), who says they’re aiming for end-of-year residential with commercial spaces to be filled in 2027.


Knowing it would come up in the comments, I peeked through the dusty window of the former Truist/SunTrust bank building, which is beginning to stick out like a sore thumb. The ownership appears to have some connection to the developers of The Aster, though I haven’t done enough digging to determine much beyond that.

Nothing is happening in there but I was excited to see the massive, quite majestic bank vault still very much intact, destined to be the centerpiece of whatever comes next in the space (which could also use a good pressure-washing).

In sum, this is a pivotal node with potential through the roof: a short walk from downtown proper, the waterfront, Morningside Park and the stadium district, and a gateway to both East and South Knoxville. It’s already home to a mix of affordable and market-rate multifamily housing, Green Magnet Academy, the Cal Johnson Community Center, the Women’s Basketball Hall of Fame and local gem Tarik’s North African tucked into a nondescript office park just across Hill Avenue.
But also, this infamous, unfortunate and not-going-anywhere-soon spaghetti pile of roadways.

James White Parkway efficiently serves South Knoxville’s growing population but remains a formidable barrier between downtown and neighborhoods to the east. Big ideas for repairing the community fabric torn apart by Urban Renewal include former County Commissioner Larsen Jay’s recent brilliant but pie-in-the-sky pitch to build highway-cap bridges over James White Parkway and Neyland Drive, creating green space and development opportunities above the roads. But again, there’s that pesky money thing.
One hopes that any future planning decisions will be made holistically, with an eye toward how we can PROGRESS toward an improvement of the whole as a sum of its parts.

III: HISTORY
I’ve saved the best for our most dedicated readers who’ve managed to scramble through all the above in anticipation of, at best, some exciting antique newspaper clippings. Make it rain, Newspapers.com!

And these legends:






Talk about out-of-the-box thinking … quite a bit later, but this was an interesting sojourn that I had the surreal-in-retrospect experience of competing in. The parking garage was converted into stabling for the horses.

However shabby and underwhelming KCAC appears today, it was once undeniably a point of pride for the City.
Christine Cloninger, executive director of Knox Heritage, emphasized the existing complex’s architectural significance: “An early design by Knoxville architect Bruce McCarty, this building is a striking example of Mid-Century Modern architecture, with its undulating roofline, textured concrete, and Manhattan-style window wall. Its history is equally significant, having hosted performers like the Rolling Stones, Bruce Springsteen, Duke Ellington, and the Jackson 5, as well as George Jones’ final show. Historic places like the Coliseum shape our cultural identity, bring people together, and connect us to our community’s history.”
Something has to give, and perhaps the existing structure has more value than we give it credit for. And $70 million is nothing to sneeze at.

What does $70 million actually buy you these days, anyway? II’m no expert in budgets with that many commas, but a few recent Knoxville projects offer some perspective. There’s the $70 million redevelopment of North Knoxville’s historic St. Mary’s Hospital into affordable housing, which broke ground earlier this month. Knoxville’s new Public Safety Complex, relocated from its former Hill Avenue site next to KCAC, cost roughly the same. And it’s about what KUB is spending to upgrade its Mark B. Whitaker Water Treatment Plant, whose 100-year-old “water castle” I recently explored.
None of these is an apples-to-apples comparison, of course. And we’re talking about $60 million specifically for KCAC. It may not buy us a gleaming new performing arts palace, but in the hands of a thoughtful, imaginative design team and some visionary leadership, that money could go a long way. Perhaps it could even be the first chapter in a PROGRESSIVE new era for these old buildings.

I don’t mean to sound overly optimistic. If someone out there reading this has the keys to a bulldozer and the funds to front some Barbie Dream House of a municipal performing arts center, let’s go. I am always team #bigideas.
But sometimes you have to make the most of the cards you’re dealt.
We may not get every “big idea” on our wish list, but surely there’s a creative middle ground between dreaming big and settling for less. An opportunity to breathe new life into these historic buildings, reconnect them with the rapidly changing city around them, and give Knoxville something it can once again feel inspired by and proud of.
Correction: An earlier version of this story, right slam-bam in the opening sentence, cited “$60” for upgrades to the Knoxville Civic Auditorium and Coliseum. Add six zeroes to that. Oops. Thanks to Tony Cheatham, my good friend who I can always count on whether I’ve got food stuck in my teeth or need rescuing from a Fourth & Gill utility pole or a hot tub I’ve fallen asleep in, for catching the typo. Although, as he pointed out, “$60 worth of confetti poppers might do the trick.” – Leslie
Discover more from Inside of Knoxville
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.






Recent Comments