Editor’s note: As I publish this, sometime after 2 a.m. on Thursday, Christa Pike’s condition remains unclear.
Earlier this evening I stopped writing to watch a live-streamed press conference, a partial recap of which is available on WBIR here. As emergency vehicles streamed past, media witnesses described an execution by lethal injection gone very wrong; Christa was still visibly and audibly alive after two doses of pentobarbital. The curtains were closed, and witnesses were asked to leave. Her attorneys later said she had been taken to a hospital, but they had not been informed of her condition.
The story I was finishing no longer felt relevant. I found myself returning to a long-form piece by JJ Stambaugh, a former News Sentinel reporter among other endeavors who now publishes The Appalachia Wire on Substack. It’s a brutal, complicated, powerful recounting of JJ’s chance encounter with 18-year-old Christa in Fort Sanders in 1995 not long before the murder of fellow Job Corps student Colleen Slemmer in the woods of UT’s Agriculture Campus. I reached out to JJ, who was still awake as well and agreed to allow IOK to republish the piece.
Content warning: This is a difficult read, with profanity, frank questioning of religious beliefs, and depictions of drug use, violence, attempted suicide and child sexual abuse. It offers no comfortable distance from the people or events it describes. But I think that’s necessary sometimes. — Leslie

By JJ Stambaugh / The Appalachia Wire
You think you’re getting away with it. Just you wait. I rewrite your Bible, restoring the Gospel of Judith, her with a sword. I declare this: Do not be about your father’s business. Your father’s business is rape and murder….Now and forever, let it all be over. — Caroline Fraser, Murderland
You think you know about pain? — Jack Ketchum, The Girl Next Door
1.
KNOXVILLE, Tenn. — On a long-ago night in the late Fall of 1994, while standing in front of the 17th Street Market in the Fort Sanders neighborhood with a ten-strip of LSD in my wallet and an unopened pack of Camel cigarettes in my hands, I met a girl.
To my oh-so-jaded, predatory eyes, she stuck out like a sore thumb from the college students, winos, crackheads, and assorted counterculture casualties who made up the population of Fort Sanders at that time. Unfashionably permed brown hair, slight figure cloaked by a sweatshirt, face only half-glimpsed in the drowsy luminescence cast by the streetlights.
I immediately clocked her as part of a clique my friends and I had dubbed the “Job Corps kids,” a group of youngsters who often floated on the periphery of the local drug scene, trying to crash our parties or sneak into one of the bars and beer joints surrounding the University of Tennessee campus. In fact, I was fairly sure I’d seen her around before, most likely at Gryphons, which was pretty much the easiest place in town for someone under 21 to buy a beer, especially if they were cute and female.
She noticed me watching and stopped as I peeled the cellophane wrapper from my cigarettes and let it drop to the pavement. She smiled, then walked up and asked for a smoke, her voice syrup with a hint of pepper and spice. From the light cast by the storefront behind me, I could tell her pupils were fully dilated, so much so that I couldn’t tell what color they were.
I asked her name, as guys have done since time immemorial, and she said it was Christa, pronouncing it “Christ-ah” (playful emphasis on the last syllable). I asked what she was doing, and she said that she was just walking.
We decided to walk together.
I was awaiting a ride from a buddy of mine — we’ll call him Jeff — since my Honda Civic was in the shop for brake work. I’d been doing my rounds for a good two or three hours by that point, starting out with a sheet of acid (that’s 100 hits, for the uninitiated) which had now been converted into a little over $400 cash in my pocket. It was a good night, as that was enough to cover a week’s rent, groceries, sundries, and methadone. I figured I had an hour or so to kill, so I turned on my best charm and soon enough we were swapping jokes.
I wish I could tell you intimate details of the conversation that followed, but the simple truth is that it occurred decades ago, and I obviously didn’t take notes (although I did scribble in a journal almost every day). But I do remember snippets, and impressions, and the fact I couldn’t place her accent, which reminded me a little of how my relatives in the Kentucky mountains spoke. And the way the ramshackle architecture of the Fort Sanders neighborhood (which we called simply “The Fort”) seemed to channel the wind into icy fingertips that slowly nudged us closer and closer together, for warmth if nothing else.
I had one more stop to make, at a cramped apartment near the old Falafel Hut restaurant on Clinch Avenue. I gave her another cigarette and invited her to wait while I took care of business inside, half-expecting her to be gone when I came back out with my supply now reduced to three tiny squares of perforated blotter paper. But, no — she was still standing there on the sidewalk when I returned, waiting patiently, twirling her hair with her fingers. She looked quite pretty, I thought, but awfully young. Disconcertingly so, to be honest.
I pulled out my wallet and removed the three remaining doses of acid, wrapped in a piece of aluminum foil. I tore away two hits and placed them between my left cheek and gum.
“You get high, right?” I asked.
She smiled, nodded, and then — looking like nothing so much as an eager puppy — closed her eyes and stuck out her tongue.
2.
Christa Gail Pike. The Job Corps Killer. Satanist. The Youngest Woman on Death Row anywhere in the country, at least for many years. The subject of countless tabloid headlines, books, podcasts, and true crime specials.
America’s Queen of Fucking Darkness.
A child rape victim from rural Appalachia who desperately sought a fresh start in our fair city but instead met the worst people she could meet, in the worst place she could meet them, and committed a deed so foul her very name has become a curse.
I know most of you hate Christa Pike, and for wholly intelligible reasons. What she and her boyfriend from the Job Corps program did to another young woman named Colleen Slemmer several weeks after the night I’m describing was, in a word, unforgivable. Unspeakable. And, yes, even evil.
But we live in a world full of unspeakable and evil things, and today we’re going to discuss some of them. Not just for the sake of Colleen Slemmer and all the other victims of violent crime, but also for the so-called monsters who do such ghastly things to their victims, and most especially for the children who will confront these evil and unspeakable things and become so-called monsters tomorrow.
And so, Good Christian People of Tennessee— especially Governor Bill Lee, not to mention every so-called priest, pastor, and minister from Bristol to Memphis, or anyone else who cares — I am here to beg for the life of this girl you so desperately want to kill.
In fact, I’d like for you Good Christian People to consider this a challenge. From me to you.
I’m throwing a gauntlet down at your feet and daring you to pick it up. To show us all who you truly are, in your temples built of gold and whited bones. Here’s your chance to finally prove to this broken, sinful world that you actually believe in the Bible you claim to have so much faith in. You know, that book whose hundreds of pages can be summed up in four words: Forgive or be damned.
Bear in mind, though, I’m not asking you to actually forgive Christa. You’ll either choose to follow the teachings of that rabbi from Galilee, or not. I’m also not asking that you pardon her, or in any way reduce her prison term. I’m merely asking that you not bloody our collective hands as this girl and her boyfriend (who doesn’t face execution, by the way) bloodied theirs.
I’m fully aware that my pleas will almost certainly be in vain. They will fall on deaf ears. Public opinion — your opinion— has spoken loud and clear on this point from Day One, and she’s lost so many appeals that I long ago stopped even trying to keep up with them all. You apparently want to kill her as much as she wanted to kill her victim, and you believe you have both moral and legal cause to do so.
Yet I still intend to show why killing this broken human being in the coldest of blood will be a moral outrage as grave as the one she committed. I’m here because I’m afraid I’ve damned myself by holding my tongue for far too long, about a great many things, including this girl we propose to kill (and, despite her age, she remains just that to me— a girl). I have nothing but my voice, but before time comes and stills it forever and I go into the Dark, I intend to use it for all it’s worth.
And, so, Good Christian People of Tennessee, I politely ask you to listen, for when the Devil gives a discourse on the subject of sin, you should pay the strictest attention.
3.
It can take LSD (lysergic acid diethylamide) anywhere from 20 to 90 minutes to begin affecting someone after they ingest a dose.
Most folks spend that time in a state of apprehension or excitement, and they often try to find ways to distract themselves through conversation, exercise, smoking pot, or even just turning up some favorite music. They do this because every time is different; experiences can rage wildly between euphoric and terrifying over the space of a single “trip,” which usually lasts anywhere from 8 to 24 hours, depending on the dose. The wait is both frightening and exhilarating, since what happens next is basically a roll of the dice. And that, of course, is part of the thrill.
You may ask why anyone would subject themselves to something that sounds so risky. The answer is simple: when it doesn’t go wrong (and it usually doesn’t) it’s insanely pleasurable. Heavy acid users have often described the experience as mystical, even religious; I wouldn’t go that far, but I would unhesitatingly call some of it beautiful. Seeing, for instance, the skyline of downtown Knoxville draped in spinning, multicolored Christmas lights and glittering strands of unearthly gossamer on a sweltering night in midsummer is a vision of unsurpassed loveliness whether it’s real or not.
On that long-ago night in late 1994, Christa Pike and I wound up standing in the gravel parking lot behind the now-defunct Laurel High School, which was housed in a sprawling Dutch Colonial in the heart of The Fort. This was one of my favorite places to meet friends or take dates at night, as it was surrounded by trees and elevated in such a way that it was screened from traffic passing by on 16th Street. It was also where I was planning to rendezvous with Jeff for my ride home.

I’m not going to pretend my motives were remotely pure in the beginning, but I can at least say they became less focused with every word that spilled from this girl’s mouth. It was clear she was exceptionally immature for someone in their late teens, and I recall eventually teasing her about her youth until she showed me her ID. Even then, I couldn’t help but suspect it was a fake; it occurred to me that she might actually be a runaway from some rural hellhole who’d found their way to Knoxville, a state-of-affairs that occurred with depressing regularity back then.
As we stood there, she began complaining about how awful things were at the Job Corps, a brutalist structure that lay at the intersection of 17th Street and Dale Avenue. The facility was part of a federal program that provided free vocational training, room, and board for low-income teens and young adults. By all accounts, it was a combination of dormitory and prison that sounded, well, pretty awful. I’d heard much of it before, as youths from the program had been a feature of life in The Fort for as long as I could remember. They weren’t welcomed most places, as they brought an element of urban criminality that made, say, most of the college students and nouveauhippies uncomfortable.
Once she got past venting about her living arrangements, her demeanor abruptly changed. She began to pace in circles, kicking up clouds of dust and gravel, and she gesticulated frequently with her hands. She became almost childishly exuberant, bordering on cocky, and veered back-and-forth between gut-spilling and quizzing me about where I was from, what I did, the music I listened to, etc.
Her eyebrows shot up when I told her I was studying philosophy at UT, and she seemed even more interested after pressing me on what exactly that meant. It turned out she had a pretty serious interest in questions about reality, and good and evil, and she couldn’t wait to tell me about them.
4.
A few weeks ago (August 13, to be precise) I stopped by Knox County Criminal Court to watch the latest battle in the nonstop legal war that Christa’s attorneys have been waging to save her life.
It was a disconcerting experience. Although I’d once covered similar courtroom proceedings on a regular basis, I hadn’t attended one in nearly 15 years. Pretty much everything in the courtroom was as I remembered, except there was a lot more in the way of visible electronic equipment. All the usual suspects were present, with a half-dozen print and TV journalists from both Nashville and Knoxville filling up the benches.
Among the reporters in the courtroom was John North, who covered Christa’s trial way back in 1996 and has done a yeoman’s job ever since keeping up with the complicated appeals process. I recalled numerous conversations I’d had with him about Christa during the 11 years I worked alongside him at the Knoxville News-Sentinel, including a couple that had left me queasy or even angry (no, I never mentioned my encounter with Christa to my co-workers, for a slew of reasons). I wasn’t upset over anything John or my other newsroom peers said, exactly — they were never anything but scrupulously ethical and professional. It’s just that I’ve never been comfortable with how the media presented Christa, probably because the life I led before entering the field of journalism left me with a perspective on such violent atrocities that, well, differs from that of more honest folk.
Yet even my stomach, hardened as it is, could barely handle what I heard in the courtroom that day.
Christa attended the hearing remotely from the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center in Nashville (it used to be called the Tennessee Prison for Women), her face appearing on a wall-mounted screen. She’s 50 years old now, a lifetime removed from the young woman who once beat another girl to death and then carried away a piece of her skull as a trophy. I honestly didn’t recognize her at first, and a courtroom security officer had to confirm to me that the woman on the screen was, indeed, the once-petite girl I’d met so long ago. (Here’s a link to John’s coverage of the hearing, by the way. He works for WBIR-TV 10 now, and his stories are — as always — a model of professionalism.)

Anyhow, during this hearing, two teams of attorneys engaged in a calm, reasoned, sterile, and clinical discussion about how much Christa should be allowed to suffer as she is put to death.
Weighty questions were posed, with medical professionals called as witnesses to opine on gradations of potential suffering, such as whether the planned lethal injection of pentobarbital may cause excruciating pain as it courses into her vein.
Other questions of equally profound import were considered, such as: Will she be forced to relive the trauma of her childhood rapes while being strapped to a gurney by a team of male corrections officers?
Are her veins healthy enough to handle the lethal injection, or will she need to be stabbed repeatedly for the drug to be successfully injected?
Will her head be torn from her body if the state opts to hang her, or will she dangle helplessly and slowly asphyxiate if the noose fails to snap her neck?
Christa’s attorneys were actually the ones who suggested hanging as a means of execution, for purportedly humanitarian reasons. I’ll give them credit, I guess, for gamely making what might be the single most disingenuous argument ever heard in a Tennessee courtroom: Hanging might be the only way to kill Christa that doesn’t violate her right to be murdered in a way that isn’t excessively cruel or unusual, so the whole process should be placed on hold until the State of Tennessee can work out a protocol for hanging.
It wasn’t much of a surprise to learn on August 21 that the judge had rejected her latest bid for a stay of execution, clearing the way for the state to take her life with an injection of poison at the end of this month.
Aren’t you proud that we’re so very different from Christa Pike, Good Christian People of Tennessee? Aren’t you proud of how very, very civilized we are?
5.
Castles.
This girl talked about castles.
As we stood in that darkened parking lot more than 30 years ago, Christa began to talk faster and louder, often using her hands to illustrate her points as she paced a slow circle around me.
Naturally enough, there’s no way I can reproduce her diatribe word-for-word here. But, in light of what happened soon after this, I’ve never been able to forget the substance of it. Her rant was fascinating, if a little unnerving, and she managed to hold my full attention for a good half-hour or so.
Based on everything that was said at her 1996 trial and in the literally thousands of pieces of media produced since then, it’s understandable if you assume that she started raving about Satan, demons, Hell, or the many uses of ceremonial daggers. Understandable, but wrong.
Essentially, she described life as a fable of sorts, a castle or castles dreamed up by whatever spirits or gods exist. Their version of a metaphor made flesh, or even just a diorama of sorts. The important thing to keep in mind, she said, was that most people deeply misunderstood what things like “right and wrong” or “good and evil” meant. We had it all wrong; our normal sense of morality was the perfect inverse of the truth. Knights were actually villains, dragons were the heroes, and princes were the worst of all; White was Black and Black was White.
As the veteran of a thousand late-night bull sessions under the influence of a wide range of substances, her rant struck me as actually rather mundane, even derivative. Also, bear in mind it was delivered by a teenage girl whose vocabulary was straining against the shackles of an obviously limited education.
What bothered me was that she really seemed to believe it, and seemed utterly invested in convincing me of it. It was like being cornered by a street corner evangelist who’s convinced their very soul depends on converting their target. And I didn’t think it was the acid talking, as she was showing none of the distinctive signs of being under the influence of a hallucinogen yet.
It was towards the end of this soliloquy that I started kidding her about her age. She seemed bemused rather than angry, and handed her ID to me with a defiant look in her eyes. Jeff pulled up just as she was putting her ID back in her jeans, and for an instant we were bathed in the headlights of his pickup truck.
Jeff and I had agreed to meet around ten o’clock (this was long before the advent of cell phones) and I was grateful he pulled up when he did, as I was becoming increasingly concerned that a cop might drive by and wonder what precisely we were doing. He immediately climbed out of the cab and asked how my night was going, then introduced himself to Christa with his trademark angled handshake.
Without missing a beat, she picked up where she’d left off. The fact her audience had doubled seemed to energize her; being the center of attention was clearly a turn-on. Her whole tone went from serious to playful, even teasing. It was somewhat fascinating to watch her entire demeanor shift as though some internal switch had been flipped.
I was also struck by how unconcerned she was to now be standing in a deserted parking lot with a pair of obviously shady young men. More than anything, she reminded me of the younger girls who sometimes ended up working Magnolia Avenue at the time. The ones who hadn’t quite figured out what seductive meant and instead came across as clumsy, like they were trying on their mom’s clothes for the first time. The ones the older women sometimes took under their wings to prevent them from getting into the wrong car or motel room with the wrong guy, or guys.
For his part, Jeff clearly lost all interest in her company within a very few minutes. When she wasn’t looking directly at him, in fact, he’d point his index finger at his head and make circles with it: She’s crazy.
Personally, I would have said “lost” rather than “crazy,” but is there really a difference in the end?
6.
I’ve worn many, many hats in my time. Black and white and gray plus the whole damn color wheel. I’ve befriended countless men and women who would be considered utterly irredeemable by most honest folk: obvious sociopaths, cold-eyed predators, hopeless addicts, proud prostitutes, and regretful killers.
More than anything, I’ve known people who were astonished when the consequences of their choices finally dawned on them.
Over the course of my life, I’ve been friends with no fewer than six people who’ve served time behind bars for six different murders. Of my male friends, one shot a rival drug dealer; two killed people during robberies, and one killed a man in a bar fight over what to play on the jukebox. Of my female friends, one helped her boyfriend kill a man when she was a teenager, and the other was released from the same prison where Christa is currently housed after serving a 22-year sentence for the death of a Cocke County woman.
None of them faced the death penalty.
Their faces weren’t splashed across the front pages of tabloid magazines from one end of the country to another. One of them drew a life sentence and died in the custody of the Tennessee Department of Correction, but the rest served their time behind bars and went on with their lives, even if the years of incarceration ended up hardening or crippling them.
Yet they were nothing like Christa, apparently. Just young people who made horrible, even cruel, choices and ended up paying a hard price for them.
By the way, do you know who else didn’t end up facing the death penalty?
Charles Manson and his “family.” Gary Ridgway, also known as the Green River Killer, who killed 48 women in Washington State. Patrick Crusius, who killed 23 people in 2019. Nikolas Cruz, who murdered 17 people at a Florida high school in 2018.
There are many, many others, of course. Our society produces lots of killers.
But they aren’t America’s Princess of Darkness, are they?
7.
Buried in the mountains of case files, appellate briefs, medical reports, and other documents associated with Christa’s case is something I’d like to draw your attention to.
It’s a forensic psychological report performed three years ago by Dr. Bethany Brand, a clinical psychologist from Maryland with over 35 years experience. It’s an exemplary example of this kind of thing, and I highly recommend it, if you can find the time.1
Put simply, Dr. Brand’s report is an atrocity exhibition of the earthly infernos visited upon children in the shadows of our oh-so-civilized society. It makes for harrowing reading, even for those of us hardened to such things due to our personal or professional backgrounds. It recounts the experiences of a severely abused little girl from West Virginia who grew up under the thumb of addicts and criminals, was forced to wallow in the floor with dog feces when she was a toddler, was first given marijuana by her mom at age 9, and was molested before she reached kindergarten.
In fact, she was intimately familiar with the taste and smell of a grown man’s penis before she even learned her alphabet. Her grandmother’s boyfriend, Ernest Johnson, was only the first of several men who would violate her in the Appalachian hellholes she grew up in.
Here’s what Dr. Brand wrote about an interview in which Christa described what it was like to choke on an older man’s cock: “She cried as she attempted to describe what he did to her… Christa showed utter disgust on her face as she spoke of the smell of this man’s genitals. Christa was still extremely revolted by him, despite more than 30 years having passed.
“At one point while talking about Ernest’s abuse of her, Christa stared off into space, disconnecting from the conversation for a few minutes. This appeared to be a manifestation of dissociation. Dissociation is a learned method of escaping when there is no possibility for escaping from the abuser.… Throughout her childhood, Christa was a victim of violent predators with no protection from her depressed mother and absent, uninvolved father.”
Brand continued: “Children who are sexually abused … believe that abuse is what they deserve. This self-blame increases their vulnerability to future victimization and depression … Survivors of childhood sexual abuse typically feel utterly disgusted and revolted by the abuse, especially the associated smells. Preschoolers typically experience choking and difficulty breathing during oral rape(s). The smells, revulsion, and terror of not being able to breathe often haunts survivors of sexual abuse for the rest of their lives … Ernest did more than rape Christa. He also ensured Christa’s silence about him victimizing her.”
With this in mind, it’s perhaps not surprising that Christa tried to kill herself by overdosing on acetaminophen in elementary school. Tragically, however, there was to be no follow-up psychiatric care for the suicidal third-grader, and the trajectory of her life remained unaltered.
You might ask, at this point, where the police or social workers were. The answers are sad but predictable. First, she often wasn’t believed by the adults in her life. Not that it mattered, since most of them treated her like a stray animal at best and a sex toy at worst. While in elementary school, teachers expressed grave concern over her sexually graphic artwork, but nothing was done. She tried to kill herself a second time at age 12, but the psychological care she needed still wasn’t forthcoming. After one assault in her teens, a rape kit was collected at the hospital, but nothing came of it. Child protective services were occasionally called in, but again… nothing.
This might seem incredible to you, but it’s a depressingly familiar story to those who worked around abused kids and their families back then. It might be depressingly familiar even now, in an era of mandatory reporting standards and less deferment to the ideal of family privacy. Christa’s case may have been more extreme than most, but far too many people have similar tales to tell. They usually (but not always) end up dying young, or spending much of their lives behind bars, in institutions, or on the streets.
Christa’s entire life before coming to Knoxville was a cycle of abuse, neglect, substance abuse, and chaos. She was moved around numerous times in both West Virginia and North Carolina, and though she eventually started getting into trouble with juvenile authorities, she clearly never got the help she needed. At age 17 (only months before entering the Job Corps program) she ran away from home with a boyfriend and spent several weeks living on the streets of Hillsborough, N.C.
In other words, she might not have been damned yet, but she was already intimately familiar with Hell.
Kind of makes you wonder where all the Good Christian People were back then, doesn’t it?
It makes me wonder where they are now.
8.
We know that kids who’ve been severely abused or neglected have high rates of both physical and mental illness when they become adults thanks in no small part to what’s called the Adverse Childhood Experience (ACE) test. This 10-part quiz has become celebrated in recent years due to its accuracy in predicting psychological and physical problems in life based solely on the answers given to its queries.
Basically, it provides a way to measure how specific types of childhood trauma can impact your life as you grow older. You get a score of Zero if you didn’t experience any of the adverse experiences it asks about: physical, sexual, and emotional abuse, or being exposed to adults with addiction issues.
It’s not surprising that most people have low scores. Approximately a third of American adults, in fact, who’ve taken the ACE test have a score of Zero. Around 26 percent have a score of One, about 16 percent have a score of Two, and roughly 10 percent have a score of Three.2
Higher scores are comparatively rare, with only 15 percent of adults scoring a Four or more. And (this is important) less than one percent of the population has an ACE score of Eight or more.
The higher the score, the greater the chances of suffering a wide range of negative outcomes, such as difficulties in relationships, psychological disturbances, substance abuse, impulsive and high risk behaviors, and violence.
Christa scored a Nine on the ACE test.
“It is highly unusual for a child to experience nine ACEs: Christa experienced more ACEs than 99.3% of the U.S. population,” wrote Dr. Brand. “I am unaware of any studies that investigated the severity of damage when a child is exposed to multiple adults in the household who expose the child to the ACEs; this lack of research about multiple perpetrators of ACEs is likely due to how rare this type of multi-perpetrator abuse is. Rather than home being a place of safety, protection, and belonging for Christa, it was the source of chaos and being endangered when she was a little girl and through adolescence.”
Since reading Dr. Brand’s report, I’ve thought long and hard about how Christa must have perceived the world, how desperate and alone she felt. Most especially, I wondered when all that pain finally turned to rage and hate. I really don’t want to imagine it, to be honest. Even if I could, there’s no way I could authentically describe what being a Nine meant for her.
What I can try to do, however, is tell you from firsthand experience what it’s like to grow up as an Eight on the ACEs scale.
Usually, one of the first lessons that such kids learn is there’s no such thing as safety; there’s no way to hide from what they’re most afraid of. They live at least part of their lives in a state of constant, crippling fear. This terror is so intense, so overwhelming, that it ends up being the foundation on which their entire personality is eventually built. As you can imagine, how they learn to confront or hide from their fears will be pivotal to what happens to them later in life.
Of even greater importance, if possible, is the next lesson, which is that no sources of authority can be trusted. Lies are the currency of the world. They realize those who should be telling them truths are doing no such thing, and they eventually figure out that even their favorite fairy tales, movies, cartoons, and fables are bullshit. In real life, they realize, good guys aren’t protected by their virtue, monsters usually win, and no one rescues children. And, even if they are “rescued,” it could mean spending years in an institution, or poverty, where their sufferings will be increased a hundredfold.
But the worst lesson they learn at this early stage of their lives is that of powerlessness. And it’s this lesson that will ultimately destroy many of them, for I’ve come to believe that nothing corrupts the human mind like being subjected to domination at the hands of others on a regular basis.
What comes next is escape, however they can manage it. They usually turn inwards, becoming prisoners of their own minds and the worlds entire they create. They try to lose themselves in books, movies, music, comics, and other sorts of mass media. They build castles, and strange countries, and populate them with characters whose fates they can control. Imaginary worlds where they have Power. Worlds where they’re not so terribly alone.
Then adolescence hits. For some reason, I’ve found, most of them seem to quickly find their way into peer groups full of kids with similar problems. When I recall my teen years, it seems — at least in the imperfect reflection of memory — like we could smell each other’s pain, anger, and desperation.
This is when most kids of this type get their first taste of the behaviors that psychologists designate as “high risk,” such as drugs, sex, petty theft, vandalism, and fighting. They rummage through the darkest elements of pop culture and pose questions that make those around them uncomfortable. It often seems like simple teenage rebellion, but what’s actually happening is considerably darker. They’re convinced nearly everything they’ve been told by those with Power has been nothing but a pack of lies which are used to keep them powerless, to ensure they never stop being victims.
It’s important to realize they’re not just “acting out” or breaking rules for the hell of it. They’re trying to find something worth believing in, and also learning — fitfully, painfully, often destructively — what it means to finally have some measure of Power, which increases steadily with each passing year.
Somehow, these young people almost always find their way into the worst places in our society, and they end up doing ugly things which are incomprehensible to most people.
Regardless what these severely traumatized young people ultimately latch onto, they all share something in common. They eventually reach an age or size when they realize they can finally stand up for themselves. That someone else can be the victim, for a change.
And then It happens.
Always, always, It happens.
Maybe they’re burned in a drug deal, or someone assaults them while they’re looking for a place to sleep. They’re raped, or a friend decides to rat them out to the cops to get themselves out of trouble. They try to pull a robbery, and they learn the hard way that no plan survives contact with reality. They become convinced someone is trying to steal the one thing they care the most about. You know, the kinds of things that happen all the time in the worst places in our society.
If they’re morally lucky, and they’ve picked the right friends, then maybe those friends will stay their hands.3
If not, well … there’s always a body bag, a wheelchair, or a prison cell. Or, in Christa’s case, Death Row.
9.
Obviously, I’ve thought a lot about the terrible death of Colleen Slemmer since first learning of it in early 1995.
I saw Christa around The Fort a handful of times in the weeks following that night in the Laurel High School parking lot (we’ll return to that spot before we’re done, but I feel like skipping ahead is appropriate here). We’d nod in passing or split a cigarette, but she never called looking for illicit party favors or anything else. She was usually distant but friendly enough, if a bit spacey, as though she were stoned 24/7. Jeff also bumped into her a couple of times, and he gave her the nickname “Crazy Christa.”
We thought that was hilarious.
Of course, we bumped into strange and freaky people all the time. Life in The Fort (and the rest of Knoxville) was a nonstop party to us in those days, and there was never any shortage of interesting people to meet. I’ve no doubt we would’ve completely forgotten about Christa entirely in short order, if it wasn’t for what happened just a few weeks later.
On a morning in mid-January, I was awakened by a phone call from Jeff. It was obvious he was upset about something, as he was actually stuttering a bit when he first tried to speak.
“Dude, you remember that crazy bitch we took home to the Job Corps?” he finally said. “Crazy Christa? Check out the news, man. Now.”
He then hung up the phone before I could even try to ask a question. I sat down on the couch where I normally slept (I lived in an efficiency apartment in North Knoxville at the time) and hit the appropriate buttons on my TV’s remote control, sure I’d soon be watching a news story about how that slip of a girl had been killed in some horrible way.
To say I was stunned by Colleen Slemmer’s murder and the arrest of Christa along with two other Job Corps students would be a gross understatement.
Christa and her boyfriend, 17-year-old Tadaryl Shipp, along with a mutual friend named Shadolla Peterson, 18, had lured the 19-year-old Ms. Slemmer to a remote location near the UT campus on January 12. Ms. Slemmer was apparently told that Christa — who suspected her of trying to steal Mr. Shipp away from her — wanted to make peace.
Christa and Mr. Shipp instead proceeded to beat and torture Ms. Slemmer for nearly 30 minutes while Ms. Peterson served as a lookout. A pentagram was carved in the victim’s chest at one point, and Christa ultimately smashed her head in with a chunk of asphalt in a gruesome coup de grâce. She then mocked and celebrated the poor woman’s demise before taking a piece of her skull as a trophy.
Honestly, I didn’t quite believe the tales being spun by the Knoxville Police Department over the following days and weeks. There was talk of Satanic rituals and all kinds of occultism at the Job Corps, with one anonymous KPD source telling the Knoxville News-Sentinel that Ms. Slemmer’s skull was taken for ritualistic reasons: “Satanists believe the body has to be whole for the soul to escape,” this source said. “By keeping this, they had the soul captive.”

At one point, KPD actually launched a probe into occult religious activities at the Job Corps, hilariously justified on First Amendment grounds because apparently no one was supposed to be praying to anything on federal property.
The freak show had started in earnest, and Christa was immediately crowned Queen of the Freaks.
Bear in mind that America was still in the throes of what’s remembered as “Satanic panic,” which meant law enforcement authorities and the media seemed obsessed with hysterical tales of bloodthirsty, devil-worshipping teens who, for some reason, always seemed to be fans of the best rock bands. I suspect most young people who dressed in certain ways, or listened to certain music, or read certain books, felt pangs of sympathy whenever another teen found themselves at the center of a similar media storm, regardless of what crime they were accused of committing.
Most of the people in my circle certainly did. None of us were conventionally religious, and would undoubtedly have been labeled “freaks” had we come to the attention of the press. At the time of Ms. Slemmer’s killing, in fact, my first wife and I were finalizing our divorce and joking about the cosmos’s apparent displeasure at our union. Four years previously, you see, we’d been married under a tree in Cades Cove by a “white witch,” and we’d both since driven past the site and found the poor tree had been reduced to blackened splinters by a lightning strike.
10.
As it turned out, however, at least some of my skepticism about the case was misplaced. The sordid details emerged at Christa’s trial, and it turned out they were even worse than what was initially reported, if such a thing was possible.
It seems Christa and Mr. Shipp were the proverbial match made in, well, you-know-where. It also seems Mr. Shipp was the one who introduced Christa to their quasi-literate, homespun version of Satanism. There’s also reason to believe at least one of the trio — Mr. Shipp — was under the influence of LSD at the time of the murder.
As the trial progressed, I couldn’t help but wonder about the castles these two severely damaged kids had built together in their minds, and the terrible joy Christa felt as she stood over her fallen rival.

And, when I consider unspeakable and evil things, I think of what Ms. Slemmer endured during her final moments on this earth.
I’d wager Ms. Slemmer’s fear and suffering were even worse than you can imagine. I’ve (obviously) never experienced the nightmare she faced at the end of her life, but I’ve been stomped pretty badly a couple of times. We used to call such affrays “boot parties,” and being kicked and punched when you’re too weak to fight back hurts. The fear is even worse, if that’s possible; lying powerless at the feet of an enemy is terrifying.
I’m confident the jury members who sentenced Christa to death were thinking of Ms. Slemmer’s sufferings when they reached the decision to take her life in 1996. Well, that and all the talk about Satanism, which served to paint a lost girl who was clearly basking in the first real attention she’d ever gotten in her whole pitiful life as the devil’s own whore.
Of course, the jurors didn’t know Christa’s co-defendants would never face similar consequences for their actions. You see, Mr. Shipp was just a few months younger than Christa and, because he was still a juvenile, couldn’t be sentenced to worse than life in prison. He even has a shot at being a free man someday, if the parole board agrees to it. His next hearing is only five short years from now.
Ms. Peterson, who cooperated with authorities, got probation.
Sound fair to you?
11.
At Christa’s sentencing hearing in 1996, the stepfather of Ms. Slemmer — Raul Martinez — said something about her that’s been rattling around in my brainpan for decades: “I don’t think there’s a human being inside that body.”
He made a good point, I think, even if it’s not quite the one he wanted to make.
In a sense, Christa isn’t human. Or, at least, not the kind of human we’re accustomed to meeting in this day and age, when it’s not considered normal to have sex with our dependents, or carve trophies from the bodies of our fallen enemies.
I find it amusing that folks who claim to have a “Biblical worldview” don’t often seem to give much thought to what that view of the world actually shows. It’s a window to the distant past, to a time when it wasn’t obviously villainous to offer your daughters to a crowd of rapists and then fuck them ragged yourself while blacked-out drunk. Or, say, to slaughter 200 men and carry back their bloody foreskins to your prospective father-in-law in order to prove your manhood.5 I have to wonder if David didn’t mock and celebrate the deaths of his victims, too, when his blood was up.
We just don’t do that kind of stuff now. More importantly, we shouldn’t do those things — the moral progress we’ve made is precious, fragile, and irreplaceable.
But every society has its shadows. Its worst places, where civilization still hasn’t taken hold and perhaps never will. And, while we might not want to peer too deeply into them, we have no business calling ourselves civilized — much less Christians — if we cherry pick what we’ll hold ourselves accountable for when we ignore those who are trapped there.
Unspeakable and evil things happen in those places. A young woman begging for her life before her skull is smashed. A young girl choking on a much older man’s cock, and trying to kill herself in third grade to escape it.
I imagine they both begged God for help, but — as is so often the case in those places — He didn’t answer.
No one did.
As the Greek philosopher Epicurus wrote:
Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?
Questions like those aren’t meant to be comforting, and they undoubtedly sound blasphemous to those raised in Baptist or Pentecostal churches. But I’d argue the entire Bible is an effort to both ask and answer them, and the closest it comes is the whirlwind that reduces Job’s agonized queries to dust and ashes.6
While I doubt Christa had ever even heard of Epicurus, I suspect it was questions like these which caused her to turn to the exact opposite of her community’s religion, a faith that had provided her with no shelter, succor, justice, or power of any kind.
Unlike, I am sure, most of the people reading this, Christa knew all about what happens in the worst places. She — like countless feral children before her — had no choice but to learn from her first steps that no one would ever save her from anything.
It’s just how this world works, isn’t it? Some kids are loved and some are despised, and she drew the shortest of straws. She learned every lesson she was ever taught, and she learned them well, and the result of that rarified moral education was the horrible death of another young woman who threatened the one thing she really cared about.
And, speaking of the one thing she seemed to care about, I find it especially galling that Mr. Tripp is barely even remembered by the folks baying for Christa’s blood. He’s the one who filled this perpetual victim’s head with images of blood and dark magic. He’s also the one who refused to stay her hand when she finally had the power to strike back at someone who threatened her. Most important of all — and contrary to how prosecutors and the media portrayed her —there’s no freaking way that lost slip of a girl could manipulate anyone into doing anything. Not even a deluded, self-styled Satanist like Mr. Shipp. The very idea is laughable — that is, if you’d ever actually met her, even for just a little while in a darkened parking lot.
Christa is scheduled to die, while Mr. Tripp still has the chance to walk away as a free man in the future. If so, I wonder if he’ll laugh at us while the girl who killed for him rots in the grave we so gleefully dug for her.
After all, that’s how these stories usually end, in the worst places.
12.
And now, as we near the end, it’s time to return to where we started.
As the three of us stood in that darkened parking lot off 16th Street in late 1994, I could sense Jeff was nearing the end of his not-considerable patience. I interrupted Christa’s exposition to apologize and explain that we had to leave. Like, now.
She raised her eyebrows and thrust her bottom lip out in an exaggerated pout, but otherwise didn’t seem too put off. That might’ve been the most surprising thing about the entire encounter, actually, because the (admittedly loose) customs of the drug culture would normally forbid dosing someone and then leaving them alone.
But it was cold, Jeff would clearly rule out taking her back to his place, and, well, I was feeling more uncomfortable by the minute. My sixth through twelfth senses were all starting to hum at once, and I could almost see flashing blue lights in my immediate future. (Random, snarling bouts of paranoia are a common side-effect of that lifestyle, and I’d learned the hard way to obey them when they reared their heads.) In other words, getting the hell out of dodge and enjoying my pending trip elsewhere seemed like a brilliant idea.
We offered to drop her off at the Job Corps, and she accepted. We all piled into the cab of the truck and took off. Christa sat in my lap for the brief drive northbound on 17th Street towards Dale Ave., bouncing playfully the whole time, and I noted that she wasn’t wearing any perfume.
When we reached the parking lot, I offered her my phone number in case she needed anything from me in the future, as I was always looking to expand my customer base (Job Corps students had to share pay phones, so she didn’t have a number to give). We didn’t have anything to write with, though, so she had to dart inside for a pen and paper. I then wrote my information down and, with a sigh of relief, bade her a good night.
As we pulled away from the building, Jeff and I watched in the rearview mirror as she disappeared back inside. We then looked at each other and shook our heads in unison.
Jeff: “Man, you always know how to pick’em, don’t you? That crazy bitch is gonna end up dead in a ditch in a year. Less.”
Me: “If she’s lucky. That, my friend, is what they call a born victim.”
As we neared I-275 North, Jeff fished a cassette from the seat between us and inserted it into the tape deck. We’d been on a Misfits kick for weeks, especially the Earth: AD album, and he grinned mischievously as he twisted the volume knob as far as it would go. I instantly recognized the pounding, distorted notes that exploded from his truck’s tinny speakers.
We couldn’t help but burst out laughing as we hit the interstate towards Christenberry Heights, singing along with Glenn Danzig as he belted out the opening lines of an infamous punk classic. I’ve since learned the song was supposedly written about the inevitable fate of horror cinema’s so-called Final Girls, but we always thought it was about, well, girls like Christa.
It’s called “Die, Die My Darling.”
Here it is:
13.
We’re almost done now.
The Bible, of course, also talks about that guy from Galilee. You know, the one who said “an eye for an eye” isn’t justice? The one who said our only chance at forgiveness was to forgive those who do evil to us?
I’m not arguing He was right, by the way. I mean, isn’t that what you’re supposed to be doing, Good Christian People? I’m no pacifist, and I’m not interested in debating the ethics of capital punishment here. I’m interested in whether or not killing this specific girl in cold blood is a sensible way to somehow prove to someone, somewhere that killing people in cold blood is somehow a bad thing. I mean, if taking Ms. Slemmer’s life as a demonstration of vengeance and power was a moral atrocity, then how exactly is taking Christa’s life as a demonstration of vengeance and power any better?
If killing Christa would bring Colleen Slemmer back to life and undo the unspeakable suffering this crime has caused, I’d volunteer to drive the needle into her arm myself (remember, I’m not a pacifist). But killing her won’t do that. Nothing will. And I imagine that’s why vengeance is such a pitiful stand-in for justice, which either means making victims whole, or nothing at all.
As I said from the beginning, I suspect this has all been futile. If no one cared about Christa when she was basically a prepubescent semen depository, there’s no reason to expect anyone to care about her now.
No, she’ll leave this world the same way she came into it: worthless, despised, a freak, and of absolutely no use to anyone except as a body that can be violated at will, whether it’s with a penis or a needle.
I will say this, though: If the Bible is at all true (and I hope it is) then on Judgment Day I’d much rather be standing by Christa’s side than by yours. After all, the whirlwind that confronted Job supposedly prefers those who are honestly hot or cold; it’s the lukewarm who will be spat out. 7
And so, Good Christian People of Tennessee, I’ve done as I promised — I’ve thrown the gauntlet down at your feet.
Now pick it up.
Choose.
And be damned.
1. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1BSEZ_lV40xlIsEVBuQV8zkvP2nSKS3Gc/view
2. https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/72/wr/mm7226a2.html
3. https://iep.utm.edu/moralluc/
4. Genesis:19
5. 1 Samuel:18
6. Job: 38 – 42
7. Revelation: 3
Discover more from Inside of Knoxville
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.






Recent Comments