Cumberland Avenue, Then & Now — Part I: The Old Guard

Cumberland Avenue, Knoxville, January 2026
Cumberland Avenue, Knoxville, January 2026

Time stops for no man on “the Strip,” but memory does. It hangs like a dead clock on the wall, frozen at the moment you last walked out of your favorite college haunt, whether five years ago or five decades.

Things change. The Cumberland Avenue of yesteryear was a lot of things, but polished was never one of them. Today, flanked by high-rise luxury student apartments and glossy fast-food chains, it feels like a different planet – “a clean canyon of glass and steel,” as Jack Neely described it in his 2023 historical essay “An Elegy to the Strip.” You could say something similar for campus itself, with all its crisp new buildings and robot food-runners whizzing down the sidewalk.

Despite knowing the Strip like the back of my hand as a student, it’s now a part of Knoxville’s urban center I barely recognize. Development has arrived quickly and decisively. I’ve had a hard time keeping up. 

One afternoon last week, I decided to go take a closer look.

A bright spot on Cumberland Avenue since the ’90s, Sunspot relocated to its current location on Cumberland Avenue in 2013. Sunspot, 2200 Cumberland Ave., Knoxville, January 2026

To be fair, the Strip has always been in some state of evolution, albeit usually slower and more organic.

Others have recounted the Strip’s history in far greater detail than I have the inclination or capacity to do here. My favorite: Cumberland Avenue, Revisited, a kaleidoscopic 2003 anthology edited by Jack Rentfro that documents the Strip’s music and cultural gravity from the 1960s through the 1990s. Each decade brought new scenes, characters and stages, passed through by before-they-got-famous bands like R.E.M., Black Flag and Iggy Pop as well as a sprawling range of local acts. 

By the late ’90s, most of the Strip’s legendary old music houses were long gone. I bartended upstairs during punk shows at the Longbranch in the early 2000s, not realizing I was witnessing the end, or probably more like the postscript, of an era. The 2007 Cumberland Avenue Corridor Plan sealed the deal with its re-imagination of the Strip as a more conventionally attractive and pedestrian-friendly thoroughfare. 

Fast forward almost 20 years. Not unlike the 2006 South Waterfront Vision Plan also put forward by the Haslam administration a year prior, Cumberland’s Corridor Plan has since been the catalyst for a surge of development. Now, we stare up at it, scratching our chins, trying to recall what exactly it was we signed up for in the first place.

Who ordered this two-story luxury Taco Bell with a late-night walk-up window, and why didn’t exist when I was a student and it was 2:30 a.m. and I really REALLY needed a chili cheese burrito? Taco Bell, 1900 W. Cumberland Ave., Knoxville, January 2026

But I’ll get to what’s new and what’s coming tomorrow, in Part II. Today, I’m interested in revisiting what remains of the “old guard” — even though, admittedly, most of it is actually not that old. It’s all relative, I guess. 

 To rewind a mere two decades, these maps in the Corridor Plan document businesses that existed on the Strip in 2007: 

Cumberland Avenue Corridor Plan, 2007
Cumberland Avenue Corridor Plan, 2007

In 2026, only a handful of those businesses from 19 years ago still exist in their previous footprint: Half-Barrel, Moe’s, Walgreens, AmSouth Bank (now Regions), Oscar’s, Starbucks, and Mellow Mushroom. McDonald’s and Taco Bell got a facelift. Hannah’s, Jimmy John’s, FedEx, University Liquors and Sunspot all found new locations across the street. Everything else is gone or has become something else. 

While not on the Strip proper, Gus’s Good Times Deli deserves an honorable mention. Just a stone’s-throw down the hill on Melrose Avenue, the venerable old sandwich shop will celebrate its 45th anniversary on March 13. An orange-washed time capsule of UT memorabilia, Gus’s hasn’t changed a bit.

When I walked in, owner Aaron Hale was behind the counter. He’s been working here since he was 19, in 1993. He told me I just missed Peyton Manning, who’s in town for business. Old regulars stop by all the time. 

“People love this place and have really supported us,” Aaron said. “A lot of folks have memories of here from before kids, bills, and all the other hard stuff of adult life.”

Gus’s Good Times Deli, 815 Melrose Pl., Knoxville, January 2026
Gus’s Good Times Deli, 815 Melrose Pl., Knoxville, January 2026

Gus’s family still owns the property, which has been key to not having had to close up or sell out. But staying afloat is a constant battle, Aaron said. The seasonal ebb and flow of the academic calendar is a challenge – “When it’s good it’s really good, but when it’s bad it’s really bad” – and corporate businesses can get by on margins that local businesses can’t.

“Society just isn’t set up for small businesses to survive anymore,” he said. “It’s set up for these places to go away. For so many people it’s just the bottom line. It’s just, did I make X dollars? Should we stay open another year? There are plenty of times we haven’t made any money but, call it the love of the game, there are some things you can’t put a price tag on.” 

Gus’s has been outspoken on social media lately about the importance of supporting small businesses, especially in the wake of recent downtown closures: “The places that keep YOUR money in YOUR community instead of filling the pockets of Wall Street CEOs are STRUGGLING … If you don’t consciously choose to support local and shop small you lose the opportunity to do so! Soon your only choices of dining on campus and in the Knoxville area will be the cookie cutter options of the Big Chains.”

That, Aaron said, would be a shame. Nobody looks back on college and says, ‘Remember that night at Chipotle?’

“Maybe I’m an old man yelling at clouds, but this,” he said, gesturing broadly out the window, “looks like every other interstate exit in the world. It’s taking away from this area’s soul.”

Oscar’s Restaurant, 1840 Cumberland Ave., Knoxville, January 2026

Just down the street, Louie Albaba owns Oscar’s Restaurant, a fixture on the strip for 23 years. They stay up late to serve pizza, pasta, sandwiches and more, although they do a lot more business by DoorDash and UberEats than dine-in these days.

Louie is a UT grad; three of his children have graduated from UT, one is currently enrolled, and the youngest will likely go there as well. But that doesn’t quell his annoyance that all students, whether they live on campus or not, must purchase a mandatory $300 meal plan that can only be used at UT dining facilities. He sees it as a reflection of the university’s insular economy: “You cannot use it at other businesses.”

A bigger question looms for the future of Louie’s so-far long-lived enterprise. Oscar’s building is for sale by its owner, he says, “So I do not know how much longer we will be here.” The building also includes longtime club Hanna’s Café, founded in 1994, which moved from across the street when the block was demolished for student housing, as well as a food delivery service called Snag.

Hanna’s Cafe, 1836 Cumberland Ave., Knoxville, January 2026

Another survivor: The Half Barrel, opened in 2005 by the inimitable Joe Smith (Hi Joe!). Prior to Half Barrel and a couple blocks over, his wonderful coffee shop Cup-a-Joe served Cumberland Avenue beginning in 1996. Joe’s portfolio also includes Bearden Hill Fieldhouse and, previously, Tapp’d.

The Half Barrel, 1829 Cumberland Ave., Knoxville, January 2026
The Half Barrel, 1829 Cumberland Ave., Knoxville, January 2026

Another just-off-Cumberland longtime bar I know a few of our millennial readers will appreciate proof of existence for: Cool Beans, on Lake Avenue since 2000.

Cool Beans, 1817 Lake Ave., Knoxville, January 2026
Cool Beans, 1817 Lake Ave, Knoxville, January 2026

One more that’s hung in there since its founding by the late Jon Haas in 2007: Fort Sanders Yacht Club.

Fort Sanders Yacht Club, 721 17th St., Knoxville, January 2026

A couple chains that have withstood the test of time …

Mellow Mushroom (open since 2003), 2109 Cumberland Ave., Knoxville, January 2026
Moe’s Southwest Grill (opened in ~2006), 1800 Cumberland Ave, Knoxville, January 2026

I’ll be back tomorrow with Part II, a deep dive into student housing, new businesses and my field notes about “kids these days.”


Discover more from Inside of Knoxville

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.